I have an (IMO) even better suggestion:
Convert the page to a format somewhat like Cpanel,
with servers grouped by function or location or what have you.
Make it so you can expand / collapse each section,
and have an "Expand / Collapse All" button for those who want an overall view.
By default, when you open the page, all sections are collapsed.
Most people will be interested in a limited number of servers (in many cases
just one) and this would make it easier to find it / them versus scrolling through a
long (and growing) semi-sorted list.
It would look something like this:
[ Dallas ] [ expand / collapse ]
Dal006
Dal007
Dal008
....
[ Dallas VZ ] [expand / collapse]
DalVZ001
DalVZ002
...
and so on ...